EP 16 Piling On
The Judgemental Podcast – Episode 16: Piling On
In this episode, Hugh and Christine dive into two headline-grabbing legal stories shaking up the courts:
- The Armand Langford Case (Louisville, KY):
- The hosts break down the controversial shock probation granted to a man with 19 prior robberies, who was rearrested for a violent home invasion and bank robbery. They discuss the judge’s unusual handling of the case, the statutory requirements for shock probation, and the broader implications for judicial discretion and public trust. Hear their candid reactions to the victim’s impact statement, the judge’s decision-making, and the media’s response.
- RICO Lawsuit in Missouri Family Court:
- Hugh and Christine explore a federal racketeering (RICO) case filed by a seasoned attorney against the St. Louis family court system. They unpack the allegations of organized corruption, quid pro quo custody decisions, and the challenges of exposing systemic issues in family law. The hosts reflect on their own experiences in family court and the difficulties faced by litigants and attorneys alike.
Other Highlights:
- Behind-the-scenes insights from the hosts’ YouTube coverage, including exclusive access to court hearings.
- A critical look at media coverage, judicial accountability, and the culture of protecting the system.
- Listener Q&A segment announcement—submit your questions for future episodes!
- Housekeeping: Connect with the show at judge-y.com and follow on YouTube (@judgingthejudges).
Listen for:
- Sharp legal analysis, unfiltered opinions, and a call for transparency in the justice system.
- Real stories from inside the courtroom, with a mix of humor and hard truths.
Links:
- YouTube: Judging the Judges
- Submit questions: judge-y.com
Tune in for a thought-provoking discussion on justice, accountability, and the stories behind the headlines.
Transcript
You are listening to
The Judgemental Podcast.
2
:We're Hugh and Christine, the Minds
Behind Judgy, the revolutionary app
3
:that empowers you to judge the judges.
4
:It's pastime for judicial accountability
and transparency within the courts.
5
:Prepare for sharp insights, candid
critiques, and unshakable honesty from
6
:two lawyers determined to save the system.
7
:We need some justice.
8
:Justice, my fine justice.
9
:And I wanna ring, be in public.
10
:I wanna ring, be in public crowd.
11
:Yeah.
12
:All right.
13
:Welcome to the Judgemental Podcast.
14
:Today is a current events day.
15
:We're gonna talk about
the armored Langford case.
16
:Armand.
17
:Langford case out of Louisville,
Kentucky, where a man with 19
18
:robberies was shock probated.
19
:He was rearrested on a home
invasion robbery of a bank, a PNC.
20
:And allegedly stabbed a woman.
21
:All of these allegations are alleged.
22
:LOL, how many times did I
say that in one sentence?
23
:Yep.
24
:Also, we are going to talk about a RICO
case that was filed against family court
25
:out of Missouri last time we did our
recap of the five different divisions.
26
:So we want your feedback.
27
:Also we did a special on YouTube.
28
:We've had, we were the first
people to release the sentencing
29
:and the shock probation hearing.
30
:Of Armand Langford on our
YouTube, it is youtube.com.
31
:Our handle is judging the judges
and just Google or search judge
32
:y, but you wanna get into it?
33
:Sure.
34
:All right.
35
:So, Armand Langford this was in
front of Judge Jessica Green.
36
:Just a super, super short recap.
37
:There was, I think it was August
8th, there was a woman was in St.
38
:Matthews.
39
:A man allegedly entered her house,
abducted her and her two minor children.
40
:At knife point, right?
41
:Yep.
42
:Made her drive to a PNC bank on
Shelbyville Road, allegedly stabbed
43
:her in the stomach or something.
44
:Narrowly missed her lung.
45
:Oh my gosh.
46
:And yeah.
47
:Demanded $20,000 from the bank.
48
:The bank complied.
49
:Put $20,000 on the ground.
50
:He grabbed it and ran and was
caught later that afternoon.
51
:Just down the street,
allegedly, allegedly.
52
:And then when he was rearrested,
come to find out he was on probation.
53
:For 19 robbery seconds and one burglary.
54
:First he had 14 years.
55
:14 year sentence.
56
:Yeah.
57
:And , at the sentencing we got to hear
from one of the victims and how she
58
:was terrorized and permanently injured.
59
:Mm-hmm.
60
:And was never gonna feel
safe and secure again.
61
:She was a badass.
62
:She was.
63
:Yeah.
64
:And so it was interesting 'cause
we initially got the shock.
65
:And so shock probation is something that
the judge has absolute discretion to do
66
:if it's a probation eligible offense.
67
:And essentially it has to be filed
30 days after sentencing and before
68
:180 days because after that 180 days
you become basically property of
69
:the Department of Corrections and
everything's gonna happen through parole.
70
:And through the executive branch.
71
:And when we were watching the
Shock, I mean, we were watching
72
:the shock probation hearing.
73
:It seemed like a foregone
conclusion, right?
74
:No, it did.
75
:It really felt like, okay, this
is what's going to happen next.
76
:Mm-hmm.
77
:And at the shock, I mean, there were
several things that were notable about it.
78
:As we pointed out in the YouTube
videos, during the sentencing, the
79
:judge set a hearing for shock probation.
80
:And shock Probation doesn't happen
unless the defense attorney files
81
:a motion and it has to be filed.
82
:30 days after the sentencing, but Oh yeah.
83
:That, that is like something
that cannot be understated.
84
:And that's why we got the sentencing.
85
:'cause we watched the shock
and I was like, what the fuck?
86
:You can't, like, it made no sense.
87
:No, it made no sense.
88
:Yeah.
89
:And then, it just became clear.
90
:The judge set the shock, told
the attorney to file the shock.
91
:So it was like, this is going to happen.
92
:Uhhuh.
93
:It was predetermined.
94
:And so, and this is a
very intelligent judge.
95
:This is somebody that Uhhuh
doesn't, this was not, I mean, so.
96
:Former prosecutor.
97
:Yeah.
98
:This was somebody who really knows
what they're doing, which is what
99
:concerns me is because it just
seemed like this was happening.
100
:Mm-hmm.
101
:This was all put in
place, special treatment.
102
:It was all perfu perfunctory.
103
:It certainly seemed like special treatment
because this is not a case and, I'm
104
:not the criminal attorney in the room.
105
:Yeah.
106
:You were the expert at
those kinds of things.
107
:You, you've made very clear this
is not your normal case for shock
108
:probation, not 19 violent crimes.
109
:No.
110
:Then all of a sudden, , and
it is not even that a defense
111
:attorney wouldn't make the motion.
112
:Yeah.
113
:Because the defense attorney's
going to make the motion.
114
:That's their job.
115
:But it was just presumed that this
person was going to be before this
116
:judge for shock probation, and the
judge just went ahead and, and set
117
:the hearing and then approached it.
118
:From the point of view that
she was granting it right from
119
:the very beginning basically.
120
:And the thing that's bizarre, like
when I saw it, I have never seen
121
:a shock hearing set at sentencing.
122
:It's not allowed by statute.
123
:It's KRS 4 39 2 85.
124
:I think that's right, but it has to
be after that 30 days, I reached out
125
:to an attorney in eastern Kentucky.
126
:I reached out to an attorney
in western Kentucky.
127
:I've never seen that happen.
128
:Thousands of cases I've watched.
129
:It was so bizarre.
130
:And I asked some Louisville
attorneys like, do you guys set
131
:shock hearings at sentencing?
132
:And then some of the feedback that
I got was, well, if the Commonwealth
133
:isn't objecting to shock as part
of the plea, they may set it for
134
:a hearing, which I still think is
a absolute violation of statute.
135
:Well, the statute says
how you have to do it.
136
:Yeah.
137
:And this is one of those things I know.
138
:It's like I get on my little soapbox,
it's super annoying, but I'm just like,
139
:Louisville makes up its own rules.
140
:Like, I was a practicing
attorney for almost five years.
141
:Tried, you know, class B felonies.
142
:I came into Louisville District
Court the first time I was here and
143
:I was like, oh, lucky, lucky you in
a different, a different country.
144
:Just because you guys say 17
acronyms doesn't mean you're smart.
145
:Like, it's like there is just this
in entitlement in the Louisville.
146
:Elected arena.
147
:Now, obviously I'm a big Louisville
fan as far as our food and our
148
:entertainment and blah, blah, blah.
149
:But I don't know.
150
:I was shocked that the judge did that.
151
:And then the fact that the judge
sentenced this man to 14 years and
152
:then probated him to his mommy's
house and to outpatient treatment,
153
:but also to mental health court and.
154
:Said over and over and over that
this was only gonna be if he
155
:gets accepted into mental health
court and is contingent on this.
156
:Yeah.
157
:He doesn't get accepted and then the order
comes out and never even mentions it.
158
:Yeah.
159
:So she didn't, I mean, you, we see
the order contradicts everything that
160
:she said in the sentencing, right?
161
:Well, and or I'm sorry.
162
:In the pro, , in the shock hearing.
163
:Well, it's like, and judges speak
through the written orders, which is
164
:like flashback to what an attorney
had to tell division five on Monday.
165
:That's true.
166
:I digress.
167
:But they do, they speak
through the written order.
168
:So in the, her oral rulings, I guess if
you wanna call 'em that is like, oh, I'm
169
:gonna shock you if you get into mental
health court, mental health court, mental
170
:health court, and I really hope you do.
171
:I really hope you do.
172
:And, and it's like, really
rooting for you here.
173
:Mm-hmm.
174
:And then he doesn't get in, it's
like, oh, I'm gonna do it anyway.
175
:And just says she was a, an order
that was, it was really shocking
176
:to release someone with I mean.
177
:One of my big takeaways from the
sentencing was that this defendant's
178
:mother is very impressive,
accomplished person, Uhhuh.
179
:Clearly he had a good family
system around totally to help and
180
:this stuff was still happening.
181
:And you, so the judge like
made the decision like, well.
182
:She's, she's smart, he's
got a good family system.
183
:We'll, just, , they're
obviously able to manage him.
184
:We're not gonna have, we're just
going to make him follow his
185
:mom's rules and live there and
not be accountable to anyone else.
186
:Yeah.
187
:And I'm a jackass.
188
:I completely interrupted you.
189
:We haven't even told everyone
listening about what the victim said.
190
:I'm so sorry about that.
191
:Oh, no, no.
192
:Go ahead.
193
:No.
194
:What did the victim, when she did
her victim in impact statement.
195
:Where she said that like
she was leaving a funeral.
196
:She was Oh yeah.
197
:Elderly.
198
:Oh yeah.
199
:She was going to the ATM to
buy the family from the funeral
200
:food, I mean, and got robbed.
201
:Yeah.
202
:So I mean it, it was
bizarre and it's bizarre.
203
:It's infuriating in and of itself
because there are victims here and
204
:another person actually got stabbed.
205
:And the kids, I think seven and
11 years old, one was autistic.
206
:Ugh.
207
:And had to sit there and ride
with the car, in the car with
208
:someone who had a knife up to
their, their mom's neck, allegedly.
209
:Allegedly.
210
:So that, that's infuriating.
211
:But it comes at a time politically
that this case is just, seems to be
212
:tailor made for people that wanna take.
213
:Some of the, a lot of the
power away from the judges.
214
:Mm-hmm.
215
:Who I still believe are in the best.
216
:Position to determine what happens
to specific defendants in their
217
:courts and the circumstances
and to look at it and mm-hmm.
218
:You ca if you legislating that
away and going back to cookie
219
:cutter, you know, you have to do
things this way every single time.
220
:It didn't work.
221
:It's been tried.
222
:It hasn't worked.
223
:Yes.
224
:Well, so, and I completely
agree, like this is the notion of
225
:separation of powers and mm-hmm.
226
:We have three branches of government and
that the judiciary should be in charge
227
:of what the judiciary's in charge of.
228
:Yeah.
229
:The legislature should be in
charge of what the legislature's
230
:in charge of, and now the
legislature, they were given a gift.
231
:They were given a gift by a judge
that made a horrifically bad ruling.
232
:Yes, absolutely horrifically
bad, wrong, awful.
233
:Don't have enough words to say how stupid.
234
:This decision was, it just makes no sense.
235
:No, and I think there's more to it.
236
:I mean, I don't think there's
any Now by law, the charges
237
:were eligible for probation.
238
:Yes.
239
:So she had the statutory authority
to probate them, although
240
:she didn't have the statutory
authority to set the shock hearing.
241
:No, but I think that was probably remedied
for legal gurus out there and I think once
242
:he filed the motion, yeah, it's really,
it's, it is important that we say that the
243
:judge had the authority to do this and.
244
:I still think it's a very
important authority and, and
245
:discretion for a judge to have.
246
:I think a judge should be able to
shock probate people and to look
247
:at the circumstances of a case
for a large number of reasons, and
248
:I don't, and, and I hate , that.
249
:That authority and that discretion is
being criticized based on a bad decision.
250
:There are gonna be bad decisions.
251
:Anytime you give people discretion,
they're gonna be bad decisions.
252
:I don't like that, but , it
is just, you're right.
253
:Handing people a gift.
254
:It was handing the other side a
gift to politicize a, a weapon.
255
:Now , I do think, and I mean
this wholeheartedly I do think
256
:that it needs to be investigated.
257
:I think there was, it absolutely
needs to be investigated.
258
:I think there is more to the story
about why this young man got probation.
259
:I don't think someone with guys, and
we haven't fully explained this on
260
:this podcast, we're talking about nine.
261
:Teen individual robberies with
either A-G-U-N-A knife or a rock
262
:or physical force used on 19 random
people, including elderly people.
263
:Yes.
264
:That is not something, you know,
that should have been probated to.
265
:Fucking outpatient treatment.
266
:Like I said, on my appearance on WHAS
eight 40, everyone was set up for failure.
267
:If this true, if man has significant
substance abuse issues, they
268
:alleged mental health issues.
269
:Mental health issues, yeah, they
allege a traumatic brain injury.
270
:But he was set up for failure
by outpatient treatment and
271
:follow the rules of your mommy.
272
:Yeah.
273
:It just seemed nonsensical.
274
:, The court kept talking about the family
support, which clearly was there.
275
:Yeah.
276
:But those 19 things happened
with that family support.
277
:Mm-hmm.
278
:And so then going saying, well, clearly
the situation is good enough at home
279
:to make sure this doesn't happen again.
280
:This made absolutely no sense to me.
281
:None.
282
:, I agree with you.
283
:I am so not jump to conclusions about
anything, but the more we've dug into
284
:it, I, the more, I think there clearly
was something else going on there.
285
:Mm-hmm.
286
:This was, this was some form of a
favor or something like that, that I,
287
:I believe with it will be uncovered.
288
:There just isn't another
explanation for it, especially.
289
:That makes sense,
especially with the judge.
290
:That's smart.
291
:Well, especially with.
292
:It isn't like we had a judge that
appeared to be on the fence or
293
:against it had to be convinced.
294
:Mm-hmm.
295
:It, this seemed like this was
determined from the beginning.
296
:Mm-hmm.
297
:And that that just doesn't smell good.
298
:And it was like, come hell or high
water because it was like, okay, you're
299
:getting shock probated even though you
didn't get into mental health court.
300
:You know what I mean?
301
:Not that I think personally mental
health court would've been appropriate.
302
:I think inpatient dual diagnosis would've
been the absolute minimum, but I, I just
303
:can't foresee probating 19 victim crimes.
304
:My issue though is, is more that just
like the judge is very clear, I will do
305
:this, but only under these circumstances,
those circumstances didn't pan out.
306
:Something happened that we don't, I
mean, obviously something happened
307
:when the cameras weren't rolling
and when , the record wasn't on
308
:that just a decision was made.
309
:Well, we don't need
those extra protections.
310
:It was just, let's just grant
it and it doesn't pass the smell
311
:test to me, it really doesn't.
312
:I hope they do investigate it, and
I hope with everything that happens,
313
:like one, I get on my soapbox
about how the local media is just.
314
:Incompetent, frankly.
315
:And they don't report
on things accurately.
316
:They don't report on the things
that they should report on.
317
:But everything is nuanced and more
complicated, and I don't wanna make
318
:blanket statements, and I 100% believe
that people with substance abuse issues.
319
:Need treatment.
320
:I am all for probating
drug addicts to treatment.
321
:I treatment.
322
:I mean Purdue, pharma,
the devil, Sackler family.
323
:The devil all day.
324
:Like if there had been 19 robber or 19
thefts of a weed eater from a garage.
325
:Put the person in rehab,
inpatient rehab like all day.
326
:But you just upped the ante when you're
willing to traumatize 19 people, you know?
327
:Yeah.
328
:Well and physically injure.
329
:Yeah.
330
:Yeah.
331
:I mean, he caused permanent physical
damage to an elderly person.
332
:Well, he was convicted of doing that.
333
:Yeah.
334
:So that's not even allegedly.
335
:And we heard a statement at the
sentencing from the victim, so.
336
:Yeah, just crazy.
337
:And then the media reaction, like you
said about just like the politics side
338
:of it is everybody just has their little
things out to be like, Ooh, how can I
339
:make this, spin this to my talking point?
340
:How can I spin this to my talking point?
341
:And it's like, let's actually
look at the root of the problem.
342
:One, the case needs to be investigated to
see if there's a connection Absolutely.
343
:Between the family and the judge
or something else going on there.
344
:And then two, there was a WDRB
article that of course made me mad.
345
:Can you imagine that?
346
:Hmm.
347
:About, they were just basically
saying, one, how it happened and
348
:that they used anonymous sources or
judges that wanted to have anonymity.
349
:Yeah.
350
:But I mean, they,
351
:we have anonymous sources.
352
:We Good point.
353
:We don't have anonymous sources
that we get up here and just
354
:say they are the victim.
355
:They are the victim.
356
:They are scared.
357
:They are the best mommy
that ever mommy a kid.
358
:Or they are the best daddy
that ever daddy a kid.
359
:That is true.
360
:That article was written like these
judges are just in such fear to come and
361
:defend their colleague and you know what?
362
:I'd be willing to bet.
363
:$5,000 to a charity of their choice
that these judges did not review the
364
:shock hearing, the sentencing hearing
and the file before they picked up
365
:the phone, the little anonymous source
phone to say, Hey, we're the victim.
366
:There's absolutely no way.
367
:Yes.
368
:I, I, I agree completely.
369
:So if there's a judge out there
that did all three of those things
370
:before you snitched to WDRB and just
said, oh my goodness, I'm so scared
371
:to go to the country club because
someone might, you know, threaten me.
372
:I don't believe it in any capacity.
373
:Well, also the threats
themselves are so problematic.
374
:Like who?
375
:I mean, I don't know.
376
:, I guess that's just where we are
currently as a society, but that, that.
377
:Is do Well, here's the
other flip side of this.
378
:No, you're right.
379
:Do not ever threaten a judge.
380
:That's insane.
381
:Don't threaten anybody.
382
:I mean, anybody like, what the hell?
383
:But the bigger thing is if there
were these salacious death threats.
384
:I didn't see any of them
mentioned in the article, did you?
385
:No.
386
:That had been, and I haven't, yeah, that
had been clickbait for WDRB all day long.
387
:I agree.
388
:I, in fact, I even happen, was reading
about, you know, reading one of the
389
:articles about this and I got a link
to something about a woman that got
390
:arrested in Indiana for making a
death threat to, to president Trump.
391
:So, you know that they would make click
bait out of death threats of some sort.
392
:So were there any death threats?
393
:Yeah, , I don't know.
394
:I mean, it just seems
that's, that's a good point.
395
:The notion that these judges
immediate, let me tell you something
396
:too about these district judges.
397
:I need a minute.
398
:Y'all will never be in a predicament
to experience having probated
399
:someone with 14 years, okay?
400
:It's not possible because you handle
traffic tickets and theft from Walmart.
401
:You are not important.
402
:You work part-time.
403
:You know what I mean?
404
:You do not have that level of
stress on you that you are going
405
:to potentially let someone out at
sentencing with years on the shelf.
406
:That's not the nature of our system.
407
:Is that wrong to say?
408
:You might let somebody out on bond and
something bad will happen, and I see that.
409
:But bond and probation are very different.
410
:Yes.
411
:Bond presumption of innocence.
412
:Yes.
413
:Sentencing guilty.
414
:District judges are not
victims of anything ever.
415
:They make $140,000 a year and
they adjudicate traffic tickets,
416
:misdemeanors name changes.
417
:Probate cases may be a
little bit more contentious.
418
:Anything else of importance?
419
:Guardianships?
420
:Yeah.
421
:Guardian jury does that.
422
:Well, that's true.
423
:Jury does that.
424
:No.
425
:So I just, the 16 district court judges,
well they're not always jury guardianships
426
:have to be in Kentucky by statue.
427
:You could have like pre stuff, but
like if you actually to get one Right.
428
:Am I wrong?
429
:I, you know, I, I I don't know of that.
430
:I've, I know I've had.
431
:A couple guardianship hearings
that were bench really hearings.
432
:Yeah.
433
:But I mean, they may have been.
434
:A change.
435
:You know, there may be some technical
reason why, the, they would be different
436
:under the statute, but I've never dealt
with, a jury trial on a guardianship.
437
:Well, in complete transparency, now
that I say this the only guardianship
438
:experience I ever have stopped in 2014
when I left the public defender's office
439
:and would watch those, if I certainly,
if wrong, haven't had any since wrong,
440
:mine might have all been prior to that.
441
:If I'm wrong, I completely apologize
and guardianships are a big deal.
442
:Yeah, no, I'll look into that.
443
:'cause that's, that could be very true.
444
:But you don't end up with, I mean.
445
:The idea of threats and the
idea that someone is going to
446
:threaten you for speaking out and
saying anything give me a break.
447
:Yeah.
448
:And just that, that's your first
thought after a woman, and like you
449
:said, an autistic child and their
sibling we're abducted is, oh my gosh.
450
:You know, we are the victims.
451
:Yeah.
452
:But none of that surprises
me, the judge, I mean.
453
:You're gonna expect the judge
is gonna back their colleagues.
454
:That's gonna happen.
455
:You're gonna expect the court
administrator is going to
456
:say something supportive.
457
:That's what he's paid for.
458
:That's not a surprise.
459
:Well, yeah.
460
:I mean, may, maybe not in writing, but
that's, that's what he's skilled at.
461
:He's a, he is a smart guy.
462
:He knows.
463
:What he's doing and he's going
and, and what he said on his
464
:face isn't, isn't untrue.
465
:That there, you can't foresee
what's going to happen.
466
:There will be bad things that happen.
467
:Understood This one though, you
didn't have to have a crystal ball
468
:to see that this was a bad idea.
469
:This was, this just was bad
from the very, very beginning.
470
:Well, and back to that, I'd bet my
house that guy was going to re-offend.
471
:Oh yeah, I, I mean I, my home just
looking, I mean, I've, there's so many
472
:times you're watching those hearings
and you can see, and everybody is
473
:acting a certain way in court and you
just have no idea that one, you could
474
:just, you could, I mean, I don't know.
475
:Oh my gosh.
476
:I forgot to tell you.
477
:So we only release this on YouTube
and he mentioned, he mentioned
478
:like at the beginning of the
hearing, like why is he smirking?
479
:It was just.
480
:It was, it was so bizarre.
481
:Everything about it was bizarre.
482
:But his demeanor, uhhuh,
that hearing nothing good was
483
:gonna come of that happen.
484
:I have gotten so many message
not happen messages and
485
:comments and like Hugh's, right?
486
:He is smirking.
487
:Oh my gosh.
488
:He's smirking the whole time.
489
:What's on his face?
490
:I completely forgot to tell you that.
491
:And it's like, he looked to
me like medicated, like in a.
492
:Mind altering way.
493
:He, yeah, he looked like, he looked
like he was, he was having more fun
494
:than everybody else in the room.
495
:Which, and I mean, no disrespect
to mental health, like it's
496
:just a sad situation all around.
497
:And not to make like, but you have to,
if you're in that state for judge to
498
:say, oh yeah, you seem like you're ready
to just go live back at home again.
499
:Mm-hmm.
500
:Everything's worked out.
501
:Just look at this dude.
502
:And so that was in.
503
:July of 2024 re-offend,
allegedly in August of:
504
:Mm-hmm.
505
:From the brief review of the court
file, it looks like there was a
506
:little hearing in October of 2024.
507
:So we don't even know what
the level of supervision as
508
:far as the court involvement.
509
:It looks like he was probably just on
probation and parole, which to your point.
510
:Judge green said the whole time,
I think this case is too much for
511
:probation and parole to manage.
512
:Oh, yeah.
513
:No, that was, it was interesting.
514
:I, that was really notable
to me when she said that.
515
:Yeah.
516
:Oh, this case is too
much for them to manage.
517
:So then why were they the only
ones that had to manage it?
518
:Yeah, exactly.
519
:I wonder if any family court
judges went to defend her.
520
:I doubt it.
521
:I don't know.
522
:I mean, we have a lot of 'em
that had experience in district
523
:court or you know, with, with
prac, I mean that understand it.
524
:I guess.
525
:We don't have anyone on the bench
that was over there anymore.
526
:But I guess when you read the
article too, McKay is quoted.
527
:And that's the court administrator,
BFF, and fan of the show.
528
:Oh.
529
:And then, but they just said
the judges want anonymity.
530
:So, you know, we all, we've
talked about on this show how
531
:judges are sources for the media.
532
:So it could have been somebody from WDRB.
533
:Yeah.
534
:You know?
535
:Yeah.
536
:I, I don't know.
537
:Anyway.
538
:Yeah, we need Savannah, we need McKay on.
539
:I, I wish he would come on.
540
:Me too.
541
:And I swear it would be polite.
542
:I mean, oh, we would have
an awesome conversation.
543
:He's, I'd have a beer with him.
544
:Oh my gosh.
545
:He is, I'd have six.
546
:He is, he is hilarious.
547
:And one of the more interesting
intellectual people, I remember he used
548
:to give the the training for warning
orders to the young attorneys that
549
:would get warning order appointments
really early on in the bench.
550
:And he would make these references.
551
:I think especially to Hitchhiker's Guide
and like half the room wouldn't get it or
552
:most of the room wouldn get it before then
a couple people would laugh and he would
553
:then make another reference about the PA.
554
:Oh dude, it's hilarious.
555
:I really would like to sit down
and talk with him 'cause I.
556
:I really want to understand, yeah.
557
:The point of view that he has on
the recording of social media in the
558
:courtroom, because it's obviously
shared with a lot of other courts.
559
:You go on TikTok, you have
judges who have channels.
560
:Mm-hmm.
561
:Selectively pick cases that
they're going to record.
562
:I think that it is not as stretched to say
they probably act differently when they
563
:are recording for their TikTok channels
than they would on the other cases.
564
:I could be wrong.
565
:But , I want to hear,
I wanna hear that side.
566
:So anyway, let's well maybe went off on
a tangent, but just an open invitation.
567
:Please come talk with us.
568
:Yeah, no, and maybe we should reach
out to him and just say, Christine
569
:won't be there, like you and him.
570
:Just have a conversation here.
571
:I'm fine with that.
572
:I feel like it was clear we ran into
him at the courthouse and it was clear.
573
:I think his exact words were me,
like, I hear you've been talking shit
574
:about me, or something like that.
575
:Oh, he did.
576
:But he also, when you said like, sit
down with us, he said never gonna happen.
577
:So.
578
:Oh, I know.
579
:But, but he, but that was us.
580
:So maybe he would sit down with you.
581
:I don't know.
582
:But to segue on to that any
last thoughts on Langford?
583
:Just like, no.
584
:There, there's more there and, and
we have our ideas and suspicions from
585
:what we've investigated and spent many
hours digging into it, but mm-hmm.
586
:It's troublesome.
587
:Yeah.
588
:There, there, if.
589
:What we suspect is there.
590
:It's very troublesome, but
we, you know more to come.
591
:Yeah.
592
:And there are great judges.
593
:We'll do that caveat too.
594
:It's not all, but it is
so frustrating to me.
595
:The exact same thing with like law
enforcement that when you saw everything
596
:happen in 2020, the fact that judges just
blindly support other judges publicly.
597
:Yeah.
598
:Like that is not helpful.
599
:At all to maintaining the
integrity of the judiciary?
600
:No, that's right.
601
:And just like with police
officers, just complete solidarity.
602
:I mean.
603
:There are horrible problems in the system.
604
:Mm-hmm.
605
:It doesn't mean that
everybody is terrible.
606
:Yeah.
607
:When no one is saying that, but these,
you know, it has to be addressed.
608
:It can't just be, well,
no one has a crystal ball.
609
:Yeah.
610
:Let's just, I mean, that could
have been any, , any judge.
611
:No, I don't think so.
612
:That, that just, this is just, there's
so many red flags in this case.
613
:Yeah.
614
:Well and that goes back to, 'cause
I'm, I take the bait all the time
615
:and like I know it drives you crazy.
616
:It's like I take the bait.
617
:'cause I'll be like, oh, you
district judges you don't work.
618
:And there are district judges
that work really, really hard.
619
:And I'm working on a story behind
the scenes about some of the
620
:district judges that are working.
621
:You know, we've never been to court
and seen more than nine judges
622
:of the 16 with open courtrooms.
623
:Right.
624
:I think and typically it's
like four, six or seven.
625
:Yeah.
626
:But the notion, I think
it's usually the same ones.
627
:Yeah.
628
:So a lot of the same ones.
629
:Yeah.
630
:And the notion like circuit judges
have a really, really, really hard.
631
:Job in a much different caseload.
632
:Family court judges have a hard
job in a much different caseload.
633
:Yes.
634
:Than the responsibility.
635
:Like the responsibility is much
different in those two courts
636
:than it is district court.
637
:I would agree.
638
:And I just think district court going
and if it was them being like, oh, we're
639
:scared of death threats and talking to
the media, it's just insulting to if
640
:it's done properly, the work and the
stress that's done at a circuit level.
641
:Yeah.
642
:But I mean, the other thing is
they clearly talked to them.
643
:Mm-hmm.
644
:They were given anonymity.
645
:They were still just blanket
support and, you know, saying
646
:basically all the same thing.
647
:So you were given anonymity
if you're really scared.
648
:About speaking out that speak out true.
649
:No one's naming you true.
650
:Don't just keep saying the same
thing that everybody's saying,
651
:repeating the same lines.
652
:And we will obviously abide
by journalistic standards
653
:and never reveal sources.
654
:And if any judge wants to talk to
us anywhere about anything, we will.
655
:But I will do the caveat.
656
:There are judges that work extremely hard
in Louisville and throughout this country.
657
:There's good, there's bad,
there's ugly, but it's just the
658
:system, like you said, like.
659
:Protecting itself.
660
:That's so infuriating.
661
:Yeah.
662
:And I will say we will fiercely
defend anonymity of sources and
663
:not giving up sources to the point
of going and being locked up.
664
:Yeah.
665
:And it is just something
we believe in to our core.
666
:Yep.
667
:Same as attorney client privilege, really.
668
:Yeah, absolutely.
669
:So we, we welcome anybody to come talk to
us with any, any point of view whatsoever.
670
:And , if you wanna do it off the record.
671
:Do it.
672
:We would much prefer to have
an open discussion so people
673
:can hear everybody's opinion.
674
:Well, do we really want 'em to call in
and crying about being the victim though?
675
:I'm just kidding.
676
:I'm kidding.
677
:I'm kidding.
678
:Give my number.
679
:So there was a really,
everyone is tagging me in this.
680
:We're gonna segue to family
court a little bit where.
681
:Both of us spent the
majority of our career.
682
:Yes.
683
:I can still consider myself raised
as a criminal lawyer, but there
684
:is a RICO case out of st Is it St.
685
:Louis County or St.
686
:Louis, or is that the same thing?
687
:I, I don't remember.
688
:It's outta Missouri.
689
:Yeah.
690
:I don't recall the county.
691
:I, it's St.
692
:Louis Family Court.
693
:Is it?
694
:Yeah.
695
:Yeah.
696
:Super fascinating.
697
:It really is.
698
:Now there are a lot of people
that you see litigants that are
699
:aggrieved and they will go on a.
700
:You know, they'll, they'll go
on a social media campaign or,
701
:you know, something about court.
702
:This, this person encountered what I
always refer to as the system where
703
:you have certain judges and attorneys
and all, and they're just, they're
704
:protecting this sort of machine
that's over there in family court.
705
:And someone was just
sort of, , he spoke out.
706
:He was critical.
707
:About that system and was told by a,
allegedly, by a friend of the court or
708
:a guardian ad litem, I think one that if
he rescinded or stopped being critical,
709
:then he could have more custody time
and just made it very quid pro quo.
710
:And then he saw the Supreme Court
allegedly introduced itself into the
711
:case and intervened somehow, which is.
712
:Wild.
713
:Really wild.
714
:So it just so happened that this guy was
a big firm attorney who handled class
715
:action lawsuits and went to the federal
level and said, well, I'm not going to
716
:get anybody that's not protecting the
system outside of the court outside of
717
:the, you know, out inside of state court.
718
:So I'm going to the feds Yeah.
719
:And make this a racketeering case and.
720
:, It's a fascinating case that he's laid
out because he is properly laid out, I
721
:think the foundation for a RICO case.
722
:And so RICO is organized
crime at the federal level.
723
:Mm-hmm.
724
:We actually do have a statute in
Kentucky, it's called Criminal syndicate.
725
:It's, but it's basically
just organized crime.
726
:And so he's alleging organized crime
by the family court system in Missouri.
727
:I mean, that's, I I am
fascinated to see how that goes.
728
:It is, it is a creative creative
argument that I think only a,
729
:an attorney could come up with.
730
:But , it's interesting because
he lays it out very well.
731
:Yeah.
732
:And there are a couple I've
seen percolating some like RICO
733
:cases or allegations from pro se
litigants, and now I've never deep.
734
:Done a deep dive into it.
735
:This article too is from Legal Newsline.
736
:And just to give like a li like the
allegations, like you were just saying.
737
:First off, this is a father who is
like a well-seasoned litigator, right?
738
:Like it seemed from the article.
739
:Yeah.
740
:I think he was a class action defense
attorney or a civil def defendant
741
:against class action lawsuits.
742
:And, family court attorneys that have
only exclusively practiced family law
743
:somehow get the notion like sometimes
they can be too big for their britches.
744
:Does that, is that wrong?
745
:, I don't know.
746
:I I do know.
747
:I do know.
748
:Okay.
749
:I do know.
750
:Okay.
751
:Like family court attorneys
had, they've never tried a
752
:jury trial, and I'm not saying.
753
:Like, listen, I'm gonna tell
y'all like there's no way, like
754
:as far as knowing the law, civil
law, you know it better than me.
755
:Like no question.
756
:Like it's not even you.
757
:But I've never tried a jury trial.
758
:You're an expert though.
759
:Like in that capacity.
760
:I know Everybody knows what they
know and smart people know enough
761
:to know what they don't know, right?
762
:Yeah.
763
:I think that's the key.
764
:Yeah.
765
:And you don't fuck with a class
action lawyer at a big firm.
766
:And he, he has.
767
:He has the, and I can't remember
if it's friend of the court, it
768
:was , a court appointed attorney.
769
:Yeah.
770
:That is basically in charge of the
custody determinations for his kid.
771
:He has a recording of
him according to the.
772
:Petition.
773
:Yeah.
774
:The complaint filed in this, he has a
recording of him saying, if you back
775
:down on the criticism of, you know,
the system, this judge Yeah, whatever.
776
:I'll give you more custody time.
777
:You'll get more custody time.
778
:Like just being told
that it's that simple.
779
:Yeah.
780
:You stop complaining and that
you might get what you want.
781
:And if that's the case, first off the.
782
:Guardian ad litem or whatever the
equivalent there in Missouri is,
783
:they should be disbarred, obviously.
784
:Let me read just like a little paragraph
from this newsline, is that what I said?
785
:It was Legal Newsline article.
786
:Matthew R.
787
:Grant, a former litigation partner
at one of the hundred largest law
788
:firms in the United States and
founder of Stop Missouri Corruption.
789
:Contends the alleged enterprise
dubbed in his complaint as the Clayton
790
:kids for Cash Scheme retaliated
against him for exposing corruption
791
:cumulating in the loss of nearly all
of his custody of his teenage sons.
792
:If true that is, that is sadly, I think it
should be shocking to people, but this is.
793
:It just wasn't that surprising
to me that there were these
794
:moving pieces that he alleged.
795
:And I think if you, if this was in
a different arena and he had filed
796
:this about something else, I'd be
like, oh God, this is so fanciful.
797
:It's just, I've seen all of these
pieces and these types of things moved
798
:around that, I mean, I've been told
by judges, if you don't stop this
799
:other legal action that you filed
lawfully in another court, I'm gonna
800
:take your client's child right now.
801
:Like as we sit here, like I've
seen this actually happen.
802
:That , this is fascinating to me just
because I, is this happening every
803
:day, everywhere, all over the country?
804
:I, I don't know, but it, I always
thought about, okay, this is how it
805
:is in my world and here I have no idea
what family law is like in other places.
806
:And reading through the allegations that
this person is making in his complaint.
807
:Yeah, just, it just sounds way too
familiar to me, which is crazy.
808
:And I think we're gonna see a lot
of these RICO cases, we need to
809
:do a full, like true journalism.
810
:We're just kind of shooting the shit,
talking about our reactions right now.
811
:Yeah.
812
:And we've read one article about it.
813
:Yeah, yeah, yeah.
814
:And so the lawsuit named, and I'm just
reading from this, but it named the
815
:judge, the former commissioner, the
guardian ad litem, the children's mother.
816
:The children's mother's attorney, two
and two relatives of the children.
817
:So this is like the whole organized
crime sphere that's alleged in this rico.
818
:And they say he's got a recorded phone
call where the GAL offered to restore
819
:custody if dad would publicly reran recant
his corruption complaints or claims.
820
:Sorry.
821
:Yeah, that's, that's shocking.
822
:And part of, part of
the allegation is that.
823
:They've sort of set up this system
that just generates attorney's fees
824
:for the court appointed attorneys.
825
:And I mean, I know that's been a big
criticism of yours for a long time.
826
:Yeah.
827
:That we're getting all
these people involved.
828
:They are just billing, billing,
billing, and almost looking for,
829
:looking for something to justify
them still being on the case.
830
:And a lot of times that
results in just creating or.
831
:Inflating conflict so that they
can continue to be involved.
832
:I know that, I've seen that.
833
:Well, and it's, it just shows the
reason to, I tend to believe these
834
:allegations because I think only
someone that took court appointed
835
:guardian ad litem work would be stupid
enough to say that on a telephone.
836
:Thinking they weren't being recorded
speaking to a high powered lawyer at
837
:a one of the nation's largest firms.
838
:You know what I mean?
839
:Like, no way in in hell would you,
you get, you get treated, and I mean,
840
:in some of the court appointed people
actually have immunity from anything.
841
:And you just, I, you know, the attitude
that I encountered so often from certain
842
:people that were court appointed was that.
843
:You can't do anything to me.
844
:I can say what I want because
nothing's gonna happen to me.
845
:Oh, speaking of, we forgot to mention
on the last episode one of the GALs that
846
:we talk about all the time, we started
off our Monday at motion hour with what?
847
:Him walking out of the back.
848
:Oh yeah.
849
:Oh yeah, sorry.
850
:We walk into court, he comes straight
outta chambers back where the, you know,
851
:the judge and the judge's staff are,
and it's like, yeah, of course you do.
852
:So this is the guardian ad litem regularly
appointed in Louisville, Kentucky,
853
:literally walking out from the back where
the judges are at the be of motion hour.
854
:And you were just like, oh my gosh.
855
:But there is, that's what I'm like,
the godlike power like complex.
856
:Is that there, is there another
word for that that I'm missing?
857
:I mean, at the very, very least.
858
:The impression of, you know, for
anyone that's, that hasn't just seen
859
:it so much, they've become numb to it.
860
:If you're coming from the outside,
you're a pro se person in that
861
:courtroom and he's walking out
from where the judge comes from.
862
:And this was, you know, it's one
thing if you're back there getting
863
:a date at motion hour, some of the
courts, and you go to the back.
864
:This is the beginning as it starts.
865
:Like we were having
breakfast, this, you know?
866
:Yeah.
867
:That's where he was hanging out.
868
:I mean, it just.
869
:Everything about it just smells so bad.
870
:And this is what I
thought was interesting.
871
:And I would love, if you are listening,
we need to find this attorney.
872
:We, I'd love to have him on
the podcast that's filing this.
873
:Oh, I agree.
874
:But he says that he has obtained text
messages, court transcripts, recorded
875
:conversations and internal communications
that he plans to present witnesses
876
:from other cases with a similar Yeah.
877
:Pattern.
878
:Of conduct, which we've seen
a similar pattern of conduct.
879
:Now I've never expressly seen if you do
this, I'll give you more parenting time.
880
:Now your case is egregious.
881
:The one you've mentioned that
Yeah, about that case makes me ill.
882
:But I mean, this, the, the, what's
interesting about him being a seasoned
883
:attorney, he knows that, you know,
okay, the public can get certain
884
:information through information
requests and things like that.
885
:But as soon as you have a lawsuit,
he gets it through discovery.
886
:Mm-hmm.
887
:He gets all of these things and
he knows exactly what to look for
888
:because he's a seasoned litigator.
889
:Oh.
890
:And is just, I mean, he's thought about
it enough to think, okay, where if
891
:I, if this type of activity existed,
where would the evidence of it be?
892
:Yeah.
893
:And where would it be in other
cases and where would it be?
894
:In, in billing records and things like
that, and he's going after all of it.
895
:So I'm, I'm, I can't wait
to see what he's got.
896
:Well, speaking of last night, I had a
genius idea about what we could ever
897
:do if we ever got sued by a judge
for like defamation or anything.
898
:You know, what we could
do during discovery.
899
:We could ask for their Planet Fitness.
900
:Check in and check out.
901
:Oh, man.
902
:Yeah.
903
:So yesterday after division five, I
literally Okay, y'all, we I was not right.
904
:Like we talked on the last podcast.
905
:My anxiety was like a 17.2,
906
:and I've been like keto and
like eating super clean.
907
:I was just like a nervous wreck
going to court for some reason.
908
:Just like all of the traumas.
909
:And so then we watched, it was like,
you know, in the last episode it
910
:started out pretty good and then it
was just like this dramatic downfall.
911
:Oh, the train wreck at the end?
912
:Yeah.
913
:Yeah.
914
:And so I was like, I'm gonna, I went home
and I was like, I'm gonna go to the gym.
915
:I was at the gym.
916
:I did a little cryo machine.
917
:I went to one I don't normally
go to, and it's four o'clock.
918
:I mean, I'm seriously out in St.
919
:Matthew's.
920
:So that's what, that's 30
minutes from the courthouse?
921
:20.
922
:20, yeah, 20.
923
:But I mean, getting, if you're
a judge, like getting on the
924
:elevator, changing clothes, getting
out of the secured parking lot.
925
:I mean, and I run into
Bryan Gatewood right there.
926
:I mean Division eight judge.
927
:Yeah, family court judge.
928
:Yeah.
929
:And I mean I was just, it was a work day.
930
:Yeah.
931
:Yeah.
932
:Four o'clock on a Monday and he
had motion hour that day at:
933
:He's the judge we talked about at his
:
934
:Like so many of the
files weren't brought up.
935
:But yeah, so you know, I think
going to the gym is great.
936
:I think take care of your
mental health is great.
937
:Yeah, absolutely.
938
:And I.
939
:Trust me, I don't get
paid by the government.
940
:I'd love to I I have never, I've known a
lot of people that work for the government
941
:that were not allowed to go Yeah.
942
:Middle of the workday and work at the gym.
943
:I've never had an employer that
would've put up with that in
944
:any job that I've ever had.
945
:If in the, in the middle of a workday
I'm working out at, at the gym.
946
:Yeah.
947
:Especially if I'm not getting orders out.
948
:And I, I am personally aware of cases
that I worked on that were in front
949
:of him that have been sitting for.
950
:I wouldn't be surprised if some
of them are still sitting after a
951
:year that haven't been ruled on.
952
:Mm-hmm.
953
:I don't think you're, you're writing
those orders while you're at the gym.
954
:No.
955
:And I don't think this violates
our judgey confidentiality.
956
:If it does, we'll take it out.
957
:But ironically enough, if you
saw some of the submissions that
958
:we've got over the last week, how
many were Bryan Gatewood cases?
959
:Eight and four are the
ones we we see the most.
960
:Yeah, I was gonna say eight, four 10.
961
:About getting orders out.
962
:I mean I'm Oh yeah.
963
:About getting orders out.
964
:Absolutely.
965
:Yeah.
966
:I get a lot of those obviously are a
little lovely seven and shockingly enough,
967
:I'm getting a lot more about two lately.
968
:Could be very brief on this, but so.
969
:There are gonna be
complaints on every judge.
970
:Yeah.
971
:Obviously ly absolutely.
972
:And judges aren't gonna
get it right all the time.
973
:Absolutely.
974
:Well, they make somebody
upset with every ruling.
975
:Just about, yeah.
976
:And even like, even if they're
batting 85%, like I'm not necessarily
977
:viscerally angry about that.
978
:I don't mean that in a condescending
way, but we have judges like
979
:Bryan Gatewood that are just.
980
:Literally not keeping their docket moving,
yelling at people, things of that nature.
981
:You know what I mean?
982
:Yeah.
983
:That's very different
than a one-off situation.
984
:Yeah.
985
:But we get complaints about almost every
judge, but there are judges that get
986
:the majority of the, the percentage.
987
:Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
988
:I mean, go, go look at the go look.
989
:Louisville, Jefferson County Family
Court and look at the responses and they
990
:primarily focus on one judge mm-hmm.
991
:Of the reviews.
992
:So, but anyway, I mean, it's
interesting to think about a RICO
993
:perspective in Louisville, and
obviously I don't want anybody.
994
:To get in trouble, like, but that's
just like so valley girl of me.
995
:But it's also like there are consequences
for actions and I just think the system,
996
:you always talk about it in a way that's
like much more articulate than me.
997
:It's this huge machine that's only
protecting itself, but the outcome of
998
:that is hurting families and hurting kids.
999
:Oh yeah.
:
00:41:39,369 --> 00:41:39,879
I mean, that's how I always felt.
:
00:41:39,879 --> 00:41:43,779
I just, it just, it just killed me
every time someone, especially someone
:
00:41:43,779 --> 00:41:45,249
court appointed where I would say this.
:
00:41:45,654 --> 00:41:47,004
Doesn't happen, the statute says this.
:
00:41:47,454 --> 00:41:47,754
Oh.
:
00:41:47,814 --> 00:41:50,064
But that's, that's just how we do it here.
:
00:41:50,094 --> 00:41:51,564
That's just the way that it works.
:
00:41:51,564 --> 00:41:54,714
It's like, but that's not the
way that it, that's not lawful.
:
00:41:55,010 --> 00:41:56,415
All right, thank you guys.
:
00:41:56,415 --> 00:41:57,495
Little housekeeping stuff.
:
00:41:57,495 --> 00:42:00,565
Remember, send everything to judge-y.com.
:
00:42:00,585 --> 00:42:04,305
Also, we're gonna start a new segment
where we answer your questions.
:
00:42:04,605 --> 00:42:08,625
You can submit them to me to judgy
anywhere, and we are going to do that
:
00:42:08,625 --> 00:42:11,715
exclusively for our YouTube followers.
:
00:42:11,925 --> 00:42:14,655
Our YouTube handle is judging
the judges, or you can just
:
00:42:14,655 --> 00:42:16,825
in the search bar, judge-y.
:
00:42:16,845 --> 00:42:18,375
Thank y'all so, so, so much.
:
00:42:18,375 --> 00:42:18,855
Anything.
:
00:42:19,065 --> 00:42:19,335
Nope.
:
00:42:19,605 --> 00:42:20,115
Bye.
:
00:42:20,175 --> 00:42:20,505
Peace.
:
00:42:22,840 --> 00:42:23,320
/ Next call.
:
00:42:23,320 --> 00:42:25,525
We need some justice, justice, justice.
:
00:42:25,960 --> 00:42:27,340
And I wanna ring bells in public.
:
00:42:27,700 --> 00:42:30,070
I wanna ring bes in public nor crowd.
:
00:42:30,130 --> 00:42:31,965
Yeah, but I To the fo Yeah.
:
00:42:32,165 --> 00:42:33,725
I To the fo Yeah.
:
00:42:33,805 --> 00:42:37,445
I to the fo fo teaser.